You tell yourself you’re trading to make money.
But what happens when part of you is also trading to prove something?
To prove you’re smart. To prove you were right. To show your partner that trading wasn’t a ridiculous idea. To keep up with another trader’s returns. Or simply to avoid the uncomfortable feeling of admitting that you got a trade wrong.
In this episode of Talking Trading, Louise Bedford talks with social psychologist Dr Rob Allan, author of Approval Removal: Finding Freedom from Fitting In, about the hidden role approval can play in trading decisions.
Rob’s work challenges the usual advice to simply stop caring what other people think. Our desire for connection, validation and a sense of worth is fundamentally human. The more useful question is: where are we sourcing our sense of value?
And trading is a fascinating place to find out.
Approval Seeking Behaviour
Approval-seeking doesn’t necessarily look like conventional people-pleasing when you’re sitting in front of a chart.
It can look like refusing to exit because taking the loss means admitting you were wrong. Increasing your risk because you want an impressive result. Comparing your returns with someone else’s. Hiding a bad month. Asking other traders whether they think your setup is “good”. Or hanging onto the desperate need to prove to the people around you that becoming a trader was the right decision.
The market doesn’t know who you are. It doesn’t care about your reputation, your intelligence or how badly you want to be right.
So why can a losing trade feel so personal?
Louise and Rob explore one of the most important distinctions a trader can learn to make:
“My trade failed” is not the same thing as “I failed.”
And perhaps the biggest challenge of all – how do you care deeply about improving your trading results when there’s a dollar figure measuring your performance, without allowing that figure to measure you?
Questions for the Interview
- Rob, can somebody believe they’re trading for money when, psychologically, they’re actually trading for approval? How would they know?
- What does approval-seeking actually look like in a trader? Because I suspect it doesn’t necessarily look like conventional people-pleasing.
- Why can being wrong about a trade feel so personal? It’s simply a position in the market. Why can taking a loss start feeling like a judgement about our intelligence or ability?
- Let’s talk about comparison. Traders can now see other people’s enormous profits, spectacular trades and account balances every time they open social media. What does continually comparing ourselves with somebody else’s highlight reel do to our decision-making?
- Can the desire to prove ourselves actually change how much financial risk we’re prepared to take? In other words, can approval-seeking literally make us riskier traders?
- I see traders continually asking other people, “Do you think this is a good trade?” What’s happening psychologically when we keep outsourcing our decisions and seeking reassurance – and what does that do to self-trust?
- How do we learn to separate “my trade failed” from “I failed”? What actually changes psychologically when we make that distinction?
- Here’s where I want to challenge the idea. Trading IS measured by results. Ultimately, there’s a dollar figure sitting in the account. How do we care deeply about improving our performance without allowing that performance to determine how we feel about ourselves?
- You argue that simply telling people to stop wanting approval misses the point because the desire for approval is human. So where should a trader source their sense of value instead?
- Give us something practical. The next time a trader catches themselves trying to prove something – trying to be right, make back money or impress somebody – what can they do in that moment before they place the trade?
About Dr Rob Allan
Dr Rob Allan, PhD, is a social psychologist, author, and speaker specialising in approval-seeking, validation, and how our sense of self-worth influences our behaviour.
He holds a master’s degree in counselling and a PhD in social psychology. He has spent the past decade studying and speaking about validation-seeking and its effects on fulfilment and relationships. His unusually broad background also includes degrees in science/medicine, business and law.
Before focusing on psychology, Rob worked across business and leadership, including roles at McKinsey & Company, private equity and venture capital, and as CEO of a publicly traded company. That combination gives him an interesting perspective on approval, achievement and identity among high performers.
His new book, Approval Removal: Finding Freedom from Fitting In, explores why the need for validation is deeply human and how people can move away from allowing other people’s opinions to determine their sense of worth.
Stay in Touch with Rob
Website: https://approvalremoval.com/
LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/rob-allan-41549/
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/approval.removal/
Book: Approval Removal – book information
About Louise Bedford
Louise Bedford has traded, taught, and written extensively about the financial markets for over 30 years, building a reputation as a highly accomplished and experienced trader, educator, and author.
She co-founded The Trading Game and has gained recognition for her unique approach to teaching trading psychology and market analysis.
Louise has authored several successful trading books. In particular, her titles include Trading Secrets, Charting Secrets, The Secret of Candlestick Charting, and Investing Psychology Secrets.
Louise runs her hugely popular, repeat-for-free Mentor Program Pro online course. Through this course, she shows you how to automate your trading so you can retire early and get on with your life.
Did you know you can book a free 30-minute call with Louise to discuss your current trading strategies?
Just click the button below to take the quick survey, and then you’ll be able to choose a time to talk to Louise.
Other ways to get in touch with Louise
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/TradingGame/
X: https://twitter.com/TheTradingGame
LinkedIn: https://linkedin.com/in/louise-bedford/
Youtube: https://www.youtube.com/tradinggame
TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@tradinggame.com.au
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/tradinggame.com.au/
Image by AI Google Labs




